PulpFest

Aristocrats of the Pulps

In a letter published in “The Readers’ Viewpoint” column in its June 1948 issue, Robert Boyer labeled Famous Fantastic Mysteries as “. . . the Aristocrat of the Pulps, the acme of stf perfection,” a title that can likewise be conferred upon the magazine’s later companions, Fantastic Novels and A. Merritt’s Fantasy Magazine.

The Frank A. Munsey Company launched Famous Fantastic Mysteries in the fall of 1939, with Mary Gnaedinger as editor, to reprint the scientific romances originally published in The All-Story, Argosy, and The Cavalier. Readers eager to experience the classics in the Munsey files welcomed Famous Fantastic Mysteries, and the magazine was joined by a companion title, Fantastic Novels, in the early summer of 1940. For most of the next year, the two magazines appeared in alternating months.

Unfortunately, declining profits led Munsey to reorganize its pulp line and cancel several titles, including Fantastic Novels after just five issues. The following year, Munsey sold several of its pulps — including their two classic reprint magazines — to Popular Publications. Reluctant to take on a pair of fantasy titles, the new publisher continued Famous Fantastic Mysteries but not its younger companion.

At this point in its history, Popular ran only new stories or fiction that had not previously appeared in a magazine. Because Famous Fantastic Mysteries was largely a reprint magazine, the editors decided to change the pulp’s content and reprint fantastic fiction that had never appeared in American magazines. Although the magazine published many classics during this period, few received the same acclaim as the Munsey yarns. Perhaps that is why Popular, in early 1948, revived Fantastic Novels, once again relying on the Munsey archives for its content. In late 1949, Popular added a third title, A. Merritt’s Fantasy Magazine.

Despite their elevated status among pulp readers, all three magazines disappeared from the racks during the early fifties as Popular withdrew from the pulp market: A. Merritt’s Fantasy Magazine in 1950, Fantastic Novels in 1951, and last of all, Famous Fantastic Mysteries in the spring of 1953.

Our featured image is an excerpt from Norman Saunders’ original cover art for the August 1950 issue of Famous Fantastic Mysteries, illustrating H. G. Wells’ classic short novel, “The Time Machine.” Our lead image is the March 1940 issue of Famous Fantastic Mysteries, featuring cover art by Virgil Finlay. Our middle image is the March 1948 number of Fantastic Novels, with cover art by Lawrence Sterne Stevens. It is the magazine’s first Popular Publications issue. Our final image is A. Merritt’s Fantasy Magazine for December 1949, with cover art by Peter Stevens (Lawrence Sterne Stevens’ son). It’s the first of five issues Popular published.

PulpFest Returns to Pittsburgh!

PulpFest 2027 will begin Thursday, August 5, and run through Sunday, August 8. It will be held at the DoubleTree by Hilton Hotel Pittsburgh – Cranberry. Please join us to salute "Pulp Heroes of the Air" and much more at PulpFest 2027.

Follow Us on Social Media

PulpFest on Facebook   PulpFest on X   PulpFest on YouTube   PulpFest on Instagram

Sign Up for PulpFest’s E-letter

Safelist newsletter@pulpfest.com so our emails aren't caught by your spam filter.

Posts by Category

Archive